• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

Excommunication Forthcoming!

My pastor reached out to me today. Very long phone call, perhaps two hours.

Basically my family is excommunicated already. I think they're trying to figure out how to save my wife before he says that.

Interestingly, he has personally in the past told me and other men that he knows that polygyny is not a sin. But today he's saying that it is.

Two weeks ago we got to start seeing one of our dear old friends. She's a recently divorced woman who we used to do Bible studies with. This is like her fifth divorce I think. She's been betrayed a lot by "friends" who have taken stuff from her, including over thirty goats. True story. Recent back surgery, on tons of meds.

We were visiting with her in her new apartment. She was gone for about two years and just returned. She was bemoaning her victimhood mentality and her recent divorce from one of our other elderly friends. Everything with her is about sympathy and victimhood most of the time.

My wife and I started talking about what the Bible might have suggested during some of her former relationships. Our friend was very interested in the conversation. She told us that the Biblical understanding we were sharing with her was revolutionizing her worldview. She acknowledged that she had been an aggressive feminist and is trying to come out of it.

That night was fun. She was genuinely super excited about the conversation, and it led to a few weeks of texting more about it. Then her tone changed. She began to become accusatory. She told me I should marry an elderly widow whose husband, a friend and collaborator of mine, had recently died. It was an insincere suggestion meant to ridicule the idea of plural marriage being an option to help women in need. She was mocking.

Today out of nowhere my pastor wanted to talk, he had some "questions" for me. I already knew what was up. So, that turned into a long debate with an awful lot of strawmanning. "Patriarchy" became "abuse." Suddenly "men can do anything they want then" and all that. He did reign it in a little bit. He accused me of being a bull in a china shop and not caring about all the chaos I was creating in his church.

Interestingly, he is a huge critic of American / western secular culture. He's actually revoked his citizenship and become a "sovereign citizen." But suddenly he became a huge proponent of modern culture and how "God has made it better than it used to be." Completely out-of-character.

We know for a fact that his wife and his mom (who founded his church) have a zero tolerance policy on the topic of polygyny. Yet her best friend basically lives with them, and she'll disappear into their bedroom and private bathroom's bathtub for hours at a time after church on Saturday night. She's already under his headship as an unofficial wife in my opinion. Obviously they don't sleep together, she has her own home, she doesn't live there.

I think what happened is our older lady friend went to the Wednesday night Bible study (last night) and started a gossip circle with all the older women (pastor's wife, his own wife, subpastor's wife) or just the whole room. He did tell me she had been sharing around our text messages and that "it is chaos." So, there's absolutely no way we're going to be allowed to continue going there long term. I don't know what triggered her to do that. It's the second time in the last two months we've experienced an aggressive feminist exorcising us from a group. We've been growing out of his church for a long time, so it was going to happen eventually, but here we are.

He didn't pull the rug tonight, I let him know we wouldn't be able to be there this weekend anyway. So we're putting it off until another date. I told him I'd like to do a Bible study with some of the men and he agreed to work with me to set something up, but it will be 1:4 at a minimum I expect. Probably going to reserve a public room at a library so I can avoid a loaded environment, but this thing is probably only going to go one way. They HAVE to expunge the threat or their wives will be mad at them. Am I wrong?

There's an opportunity here. What would you do?
 
You are in great company, check out the threads about the left foot of fellowship.

The enemy of our souls hates and fears this truth greatly. When you start sharing it you become a target lit up in neon on his radar.
New levels, new devils kinda thing.

Do your best to bring them the truth, but know that tradition generally wins out for them.
 
Most modern Christians are catholic affirming, whether they realize it or not!

Proverbs 17:15 says ANYONE who moves the line from where YHWH put it is abomination to Him. Condemning the just is as wrong as justifying the wicked.

They prefer to practice the "mystery of lawlessness" and sit as gods of their own hearts, elevating their own opinions above the Wisdom of YHWH.

This is the testimony of our daughter's father in law. This is all too typical.


Don't expect anything less from...men?...guys... who reward behavior in their wives that the Bible says is like witchcraft.
 
the nice things you say about your pastor - especially that he has said polygamy is permissible - makes me think he's just in a managerial panic and he might be amenable to the sort of reasoning:

"chaos?" what chaos? women gossiping with each other in text messages? that's their problem, not yours, not mine. i dont think you have to step in.

trying to defend polygamy from a 0 starting point with some randos in your church is going to go very poorly in a sit-down conversation. people have their misinformed agenda and they arent quick to learn they are wrong about something so important in this kind of setting. people in general have extremely narrow context windows and won't be able to track your arguments in a live setting.

if you want to do this i advise to do it in a group text or something, not live. that lets everyone think and lets you be thorough and most importantly keeps the context window wide open.
 
people in general have extremely narrow context windows and won't be able to track your arguments in a live setting.
This is very true. Between the cognitive dissonance and the severe indoctrination they already have on the subject, they really have NO HOPE of comprehending the substance of the discussion in real time.
if you want to do this i advise to do it in a group text or something, not live. that lets everyone think and lets you be thorough and most importantly keeps the context window wide open.
Group text or email leaves no room for people to go back on what they said or lie about it later. It also makes it obvious when they IGNORE your points, which they will.
 
the nice things you say about your pastor - especially that he has said polygamy is permissible - makes me think he's just in a managerial panic and he might be amenable to the sort of reasoning:
This is likely the biggest factor.

I’m not sure the size of the church but if he’s a full time hireling, then his whole livelihood is wrapped up in maintaining order. If the women of the church are in an uproar, that likely won’t happen until the bee in their bonnets is removed (you).

It’s simple economics. Losing you is easier than a whole congregation.
 
some pastors can still have some high amount of integrity despite this. i wouldn't assume not without insight from op
This is always wise but most of us are responding with experience in churches for many years. It’s not usually a polygyny issue. Other matters crop up in churches, but there are often patterns.
 
This is likely the biggest factor.

I’m not sure the size of the church but if he’s a full time hireling, then his whole livelihood is wrapped up in maintaining order. If the women of the church are in an uproar, that likely won’t happen until the bee in their bonnets is removed (you).

It’s simple economics. Losing you is easier than a whole congregation.

Yeah, I feel this. Also Revolting Man is probably correct.

It is a small church. Him and his wife, their adult children, his mom and dad, their few friends. Three families, an older couple, our older lady friend. A few ocxassioanl recurring people, maybe a dozen but only one of them at a time every so often. Usually about 13-15 adults and about 10-15 kids depending upon attendance.

Lots of family pressure on him, almost all female. One time during a Genesis reading - after the service - I pointed out to the pastor's wife how Leah said that God blessed her because she gave her servant to her husband. It was a lighthearted comment.

She immediately got mad and snapped back "well she was wrong, wasn't she!" She's a good friend of ours in a general sense though but she keeps her home on lock pretty well.
 
Basically my family is excommunicated already. I think they're trying to figure out how to save my wife before he says that.
Been there, done that.
Today out of nowhere my pastor wanted to talk, he had some "questions" for me. I already knew what was up. So, that turned into a long debate with an awful lot of strawmanning. "Patriarchy" became "abuse." Suddenly "men can do anything they want then" and all that. He did reign it in a little bit. He accused me of being a bull in a china shop and not caring about all the chaos I was creating in his church.
You are the messenger with the message they can't refute from the Bible so.... shoot the messenger!
They HAVE to expunge the threat or their wives will be mad at them. Am I wrong?
If they don't, it would mean the men might want to do the same and their wives will divorce them. Actually, that seems to be the main reason for the wives demanding you are booted out. It's like a warning shot to their own husbands.

They already have the verdict; they just need to conduct the trial now to legitimize it. Same as the religious hierarchy did with our Lord. There's nothing new under the sun.
 
I have a similar situation, where I am not allowed to attend any event except for basically men's events, which I attend regularly. It is indeed a chance to influence! I even had a full blown conversation with a retired army colonel, who recently was asked to speak at the men's prayer breakfast. Yes, the conversation was at the Thursday morning men's prayer breakfast, and we ended up agreeing that while polygyny is not for everyone, it is not a sin! That was pretty radical!
 
Came in over text message:

1 Cor 5:9-13 I wrote you in my letter not to associate with immoral people; I did not at all mean with the immoral people of this world, or with the covetous and swindlers, or with idolaters, for then you would have to go out of the world. But [fn]actually, I wrote to you not to associate [fn]with any so-called brother if he is an immoral person, or covetous, or an idolater, or a reviler, or a drunkard, or a swindler—not even to eat with such a one. For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Do you not judge those who are within the church? But those who are outside, God [fn]judges. REMOVE THE WICKED MAN FROM AMONG YOURSELVES.

As I prayed and meditated on our conversation, God further confirmed to me the direction I must take. It is with sadness of heart that I give you both notice that you are no longer welcome at Servants of the Messiah, nor at any of my family’s property, nor will we receive any mail…any and all mail will be returned to sender. This also means that my offer to have such discussions no longer stands. Scripture is clear to get the evildoers out of our midst…all communications will stop. A public notice was given to all in attendance at yesterday’s Shabbat service as well.
 
Came in over text message:

1 Cor 5:9-13 I wrote you in my letter not to associate with immoral people; I did not at all mean with the immoral people of this world, or with the covetous and swindlers, or with idolaters, for then you would have to go out of the world. But [fn]actually, I wrote to you not to associate [fn]with any so-called brother if he is an immoral person, or covetous, or an idolater, or a reviler, or a drunkard, or a swindler—not even to eat with such a one. For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Do you not judge those who are within the church? But those who are outside, God [fn]judges. REMOVE THE WICKED MAN FROM AMONG YOURSELVES.

As I prayed and meditated on our conversation, God further confirmed to me the direction I must take. It is with sadness of heart that I give you both notice that you are no longer welcome at Servants of the Messiah, nor at any of my family’s property, nor will we receive any mail…any and all mail will be returned to sender. This also means that my offer to have such discussions no longer stands. Scripture is clear to get the evildoers out of our midst…all communications will stop. A public notice was given to all in attendance at yesterday’s Shabbat service as well.
Bee from bonnet removed.

It’s unfortunate, but predicted by many on this forum. It’s not a welcome viewpoint by 99% of supposedly Bible honoring congregations.

Be strong. As others have mentioned, this isn’t your sole opportunity to support this doctrine. I’ve had the opportunity to delicately bring up the topic to pastors, missionaries, laymen, and coworkers under a variety of circumstances. It usually ends up somewhere close to “I agree that it WASN’T unlawful, but not appropriate for our times.” I count that much as a win. Somewhere along the way, someone will water what I’ve sown.

You’ve sown a seed.
 
This also means that my offer to have such discussions no longer stands.
Sooo.... he doesn't want to have to discuss this issue he has no proof for(?) There's ample evidence to prove his position (and that of the women ruling over him) is indefensible biblically. Rather than face defeat and humiliation he shuts the door. Sad.

It's only when one is under considerable pressure that his or her weaknesses become apparent. This man has shown how weak he is when it comes to his understanding of marriage, and he refuses to be open to learn. That being the case, you may have been spared from some greater disaster that remaining under his influence might bring.

May your stand for the truth of Holy Scripture convict his conscience as he caves in to the pressure from mere mortals. Shalom
 
Came in over text message:

1 Cor 5:9-13 I wrote you in my letter not to associate with immoral people; I did not at all mean with the immoral people of this world, or with the covetous and swindlers, or with idolaters, for then you would have to go out of the world. But [fn]actually, I wrote to you not to associate [fn]with any so-called brother if he is an immoral person, or covetous, or an idolater, or a reviler, or a drunkard, or a swindler—not even to eat with such a one. For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Do you not judge those who are within the church? But those who are outside, God [fn]judges. REMOVE THE WICKED MAN FROM AMONG YOURSELVES.

As I prayed and meditated on our conversation, God further confirmed to me the direction I must take. It is with sadness of heart that I give you both notice that you are no longer welcome at Servants of the Messiah, nor at any of my family’s property, nor will we receive any mail…any and all mail will be returned to sender. This also means that my offer to have such discussions no longer stands. Scripture is clear to get the evildoers out of our midst…all communications will stop. A public notice was given to all in attendance at yesterday’s Shabbat service as well.
Matthew 25:40
The King will reply, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me.’

He might as well of ex-communicated the Savior and Messiah - who came in the Father’s name - YAH (I AM) is Salvation - because YAH described himself being married to two wives in Ezekiel 23. I guess the Savior of men is not welcome either - apparently for them the King and Lawgiver is an immoral and evil Creator. Which fulfills his warning in John’s account - “If the world hates you - know it hated me first.” And in Matthew’s account - “You can’t put new wine into old wine skins. It will just pour out. New wine calls for new wine skins.”

Just like they preach a different Jesus in these churches - they also preach a different Paul. Through their ignorance of truth they misquote Paul’s letters - as Peter warns - to their own destruction. And many can’t even accept the truth so they can repent and be saved - truth to many goes from one ear to another (Matthew 13:13).
 
Last edited:
Came in over text message:

1 Cor 5:9-13 I wrote you in my letter not to associate with immoral people; I did not at all mean with the immoral people of this world, or with the covetous and swindlers, or with idolaters, for then you would have to go out of the world. But [fn]actually, I wrote to you not to associate [fn]with any so-called brother if he is an immoral person, or covetous, or an idolater, or a reviler, or a drunkard, or a swindler—not even to eat with such a one. For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Do you not judge those who are within the church? But those who are outside, God [fn]judges. REMOVE THE WICKED MAN FROM AMONG YOURSELVES.

As I prayed and meditated on our conversation, God further confirmed to me the direction I must take. It is with sadness of heart that I give you both notice that you are no longer welcome at Servants of the Messiah, nor at any of my family’s property, nor will we receive any mail…any and all mail will be returned to sender. This also means that my offer to have such discussions no longer stands. Scripture is clear to get the evildoers out of our midst…all communications will stop. A public notice was given to all in attendance at yesterday’s Shabbat service as well.
Bro.. I am sorry for the way they handled this haphazardly and without the effort the Bereans would have put into it. No one is shocked, yourself included I am sure.

It is a way to handle the sinners, that don't have a sin associated with the sin we are accusing them of.

They fear God so much they are afraid to read his word. "Lordy, lordy, what if it is contrary to what we have been preaching in church!"

I pray that you find fellowship none the less.... Shalom...
 
Thanks for your kind words everyone. Honestly I wasn't expecting this, I thought it would be a few opportunities to talk about it. But, I knew it was a foregone conclusion anyway.

I did write back. He probably blocked me on his own device but the message notified me that a device had received it, which may have been his wife's. They have that messaging app on a few devices:

--------------------------------

I wouldn't think to define what is sin from what is not sin. We have the Bible to tell us. I've said nothing which isn't backed up clearly and explicitly in scripture.

I spoke nothing to you which the Bible describes as immoral, haven't acted with covetousness, examine idolatry in the modern world as a primary focus, speak not with revulsion, am not a drunk, nor have I swindled anyone.

God judges.

I have personally heard you speak directly from the pulpit that what we were talking about was not a sin. Straight from your mouth. You stood in the hallway with Levi and I and you and him both agreed that it is not a sin, and I wasn't even participating in that conversation. You have always said you believe it is a bad idea, you've never endorsed it, but on at least three occasions I can remember - you personally Aaron have stated that it is not sin.

The entire point of feminism is to destroy marriages and families. This is exactly why it was created. What is happening now is simply the fruit of the inversion.

I am not upset at you. I understand that you do not have any choice in this matter and that it's far bigger than either you or I.

I would like to ask you to meet me to let me get the final packages I have coming there but if you choose to decide not to, then I am fine with that as well. I understand that the scrutiny upon you is greater than you can bear. It's nothing to do with you, you're a good man. Thank you for all your support.

Be at peace.
 
that's a nice way to end it.

since he wants to apply pauline ecclesiology to you then you could let him know you're entitled to fair trial and appeal before excommunication (death). if you like. or even if you don't like, and he won't, it at least gives him the word to guilt and hopefully convict him at some point.

anyway, remember job. he didn't do anything to deserve his suffering. god was happy with him. be in prayer, youll be in mine.
 
Thanks for your kind words everyone. Honestly I wasn't expecting this, I thought it would be a few opportunities to talk about it. But, I knew it was a foregone conclusion anyway.

I did write back. He probably blocked me on his own device but the message notified me that a device had received it, which may have been his wife's. They have that messaging app on a few devices:

--------------------------------

I wouldn't think to define what is sin from what is not sin. We have the Bible to tell us. I've said nothing which isn't backed up clearly and explicitly in scripture.

I spoke nothing to you which the Bible describes as immoral, haven't acted with covetousness, examine idolatry in the modern world as a primary focus, speak not with revulsion, am not a drunk, nor have I swindled anyone.

God judges.

I have personally heard you speak directly from the pulpit that what we were talking about was not a sin. Straight from your mouth. You stood in the hallway with Levi and I and you and him both agreed that it is not a sin, and I wasn't even participating in that conversation. You have always said you believe it is a bad idea, you've never endorsed it, but on at least three occasions I can remember - you personally Aaron have stated that it is not sin.

The entire point of feminism is to destroy marriages and families. This is exactly why it was created. What is happening now is simply the fruit of the inversion.

I am not upset at you. I understand that you do not have any choice in this matter and that it's far bigger than either you or I.

I would like to ask you to meet me to let me get the final packages I have coming there but if you choose to decide not to, then I am fine with that as well. I understand that the scrutiny upon you is greater than you can bear. It's nothing to do with you, you're a good man. Thank you for all your support.

Be at peace.
That is a most gracious way to conclude. You haven't treated him in the way he treated you, blocking you. At least it leaves the door unlocked if he ever wants to come back to you. Shalom
 
Back
Top