• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

Don't Go There!

maddog2

New Member
Did I get your attention? My question is about submission. Is it possible we are misreading the "mutual submission" phrase and misapplying it to marriage when it doesn't have ANYTHING to do with the marriage relationship but rather the MEN'S relationship with MEN? Patriarchal headship would be antithetical to any situation involving a man submitting to a woman. Practically, if a man is to be lead, it is more effective if another man leads him. If a church is being built, it is far easier to gain a family AFTER the man is converted. Conversely, the children brought to Sunday School on the bus seldom results in dear old dad coming to church or getting saved. Similarly, if wifey comes to church and gets saved before hubs, his conversion generally is a long ways off but, a husband getting saved first more often results in the rest of the fam following suit.
Men reaching men, men submitting to men, is a far more effective tool than man submitting to wifey dear. Men know how to talk to men whereas women most often don't have a clue.
Culturally speaking, the letters to various churches were written to men who would share with their women and family. The principles apply to both genders but the direction of doctrinal letters is to family leaders. There are a few specific exceptions, Lydia, etc. but the overarching idea was the then patriarchal structure.
We must be aware of our own post-modern-feminist lenses as we look into scriptures.
Mutual submission- man to woman and woman to man (husband and wives), doesn't work. Both empirical and anecdotal evidence proves it out.

Maddog
 
Nope, I don't :) That's why I was curious. I find it hard to submit regardless of gender. I find it easier to communicate with men. Women think more differently than men from my perspective. But communicating and submission aren't the same. Submission involves trust. I seem as unlikely to trust men as women. Because of the ease of communication I can often trust the reasoning of a man, but I suppose I suspect his motives more, because being like me, I know his evil more fully.
Which particular verse on submission are you referring too? There is one that seems specifically about marital relationship, and another to each other in Christ?
 
Eph 5:21 Submitting yourselves one to another in the fear of God. The follow on verse specifically refers to women submitting to husbands. Most men understand men and communicating is the first step toward submitting to another person's authority. I have had plenty of women bosses, some good, some bad. The scriptural mandate is for a woman to NOT grab authority(usurp) from men, as is her fallen tendency from the fall (vis-a-vis Genesis), in a God endorsed setting. The rest of the world notwithstanding, God's ordained institutions should run according to His rules. His rules don't apply to the worlds' children- The father doesn't chastise the neighbor's children, only his own. As well, if someone has a problem with my child, I should be involved in the correction.

M
 
I have often had this same thought especially as some go so far as to say I should submit to my friend's wife as we are all part of the body of Christ. In what instance would I submit to anyone but the Lord? I see in 1 Cor. 14 the men speaking in the gathering of the saints, prophesying, praying, speaking in a tongue or interpreting. I see the women silent in this gathering, no matter whether they are gifted or not they would be out of place to lead in an authoritative or representative role. That being said, the address of the whole chapter is to brethren, men, him, etc. with specific note for the ladies to keep silent, not permitted to speak, and to ask questions to their husbands at home.

When we are doing all these things, we all gathered as a body must submit not only to the elders who have been given a charge to lead well and live as examples, but also to submit one to another. I think 1 Cor. 14:30,31 makes complete sense in light of this also.
 
strongs
1) to arrange under, to subordinate

2) to subject, put in subjection

3) to subject one's self, obey

4) to submit to one's control

5) to yield to one's admonition or advice

6) to obey, be subject

This word was a Greek military term meaning "to arrange [troop divisions] in a military fashion under the command of a leader". In non-military use, it was "a voluntary attitude of giving in, cooperating, assuming responsibility, and carrying a burden".
we are supposed to voluntarily work together, i have heard it explained "to arrange ones self around".
in this way i often "submit" to my own wives. i arrange myself around them as needed. it is a choice made with position and authority intact.

when we meet at retreat, there is not SUBMISSION required, we just arrange ourselves around our fellow believers and have a great retreat, following the plans laid out by the ones who have organized it, male or female.
 
Maddog, thankyou. I've never fully understood how this whole "mutual submission" thing was supposed to work, thanks for getting me to reread the passage and see it in a new light. I found the below page on this, which clarifies it very well, from the Greek:
http://www.rockvalleybiblechurch.org/ResourceLibrary/MythOfMutualSubmission.htm

"Submit one to another" does not mean that everybody has to submit to everybody else. It just means that some people are to submit to others: wives to husbands, children to parents, men to other men in authority over them. This verse is simply a command to respect the Divinely-appointed patriarchal authority structures established in scripture, that is all.

Now it all makes sense and is finally consistent with the rest of scripture in my mind! I love it when you turn an ill-fitting piece of the puzzle upside down and find just drops neatly into place... :D
 
Back
Top